Cop-Misconduct Experts to Testify About Chicago
 
                
 
  Jack Bouboushian reporting        No. of views: 433
  CHICAGO (CN) - A waitress brutally beaten by a Chicago police officer in 2007 will be allowed to submit some expert testimony on a citywide "code of silence" regarding police misconduct, a federal judger ruled.

Karolina Obrycka said she was attacked in February 2007 while working as a bartender-waitress at Jesse's Shortstop Inn in Chicago. According to the court's description of Obrycka's complaint, "Defendant Officer Abbate - an off-duty Chicago police officer who had been drinking at the bar that evening approached Plaintiff after she refused to serve him additional alcoholic beverages. With no warning, Defendant Officer Abbate proceeded to viciously beat, kick, and punch Plaintiff."

The abuse did not end there. "Plaintiff alleges specific facts which, she contends, unequivocally demonstrate that the City conducted a sham investigation into the incident, in bad faith, and designed to protect Defendant Officer Abbate."

Obrycka also claims that "the City has de facto policies and practices of concealing officer misconduct, of failing to sufficiently investigate allegations of officer misconduct, and of investigating complaints against off-duty police officers differently than it investigates complaints against other citizens."

These policies allegedly allow officers to abuse citizens "with impunity and without fear of official consequences."

In recent weeks, U.S. District Judge Amy St. Eve rejected Chicago's attempts to sideline two witnesses proffered by Obrycka.

Dr. Steven Whitman, a statistician and epidemiologist, authored an expert report for the plaintiff, analyzing data regarding officer misconduct and complaints against the Chicago police.

Whitman's report states that "the probability of an excessive force complaint being sustained in the City is very low," and that "the situation is even gloomier than these data would suggest."

He focused on the variable of whether a given complaint rendered against the police was "sustained" or dismissed.

"Dr. Whitman [...] observes that the 'true' sustained rate is likely considerably lower than his calculations suggest due to citizens underreporting complaints and the Police Board's frequent reversals of 'sustained' findings," according to St. Eve's June 29 decision.

Data regarding police charged with driving under the influence also points toward "a code of silence," Whitman found.

"He arrives at this conclusion because, in his opinion, 'the most likely explanation for so few arrests is that off-duty CPD officers are pulled over for DUI and then let go when the potential arresting officer finds out that the potential DUI driver is also an officer,'" St. Eve wrote.

The judge did sustain part of Chicago's attack on Whitman's credentials and findings.

In a lengthy discussion of Whitman's data-gathering and analytic methods, as well as his conclusion that a "code of silence" exists within the Chicago Police Department, St. Eve excluded the expert's qualitative conclusions.

"Dr. Whitman has no education, training, or professional experience in criminology" in spite of his "impressive credentials and experience as a biostatistician and epidemiologist."

"By his own admission, he knows nothing about police departments, police misconduct, investigations into police misconduct, or the process by which the CPD disciplines its police officers," St. Eve wrote.

Obrycka can still rely on Whitman's quantitative data in part, the judge ruled.

St. Eve upheld Whitman's findings regarding sustained rates of investigations into police misconduct in various police districts "[b]ecause [he] based his analyses ... on reliable evidence and arrived at reasonably informed estimates."

Whitman will also be allowed to use on a federal Department of Justice report titled "Citizen Complaints about Police Use of Force," which "presents data on citizen complaints about use of force and complaint dispositions in large [police] agencies."

About a week after ruling on Whitman's testimony, the judge decided that Obrycka could also submit expert testimony from Lou Reiter, a police practices consultant and former officer of the Los Angeles Police Department.

Reiter opined that "the CPD has created an organizational environment where the Code of Silence and deficient administrative investigations and disciplinary procedures are present and would allow police officers to engage in misconduct with little fear of sanction. This adverse environment ... is the product of acts and/or omissions by the Police Department to conduct itself in a manner contrary to reasonable and generally accepted police practices.

"These observations were similar to those I've made in past cases involving the Chicago Police Department," Reiter concluded.

Noting the consultant's "impressive background that includes twenty years as a member of the [LAPD]," St. Eve rejected Chicago's motion to exclude his testimony on grounds of relevance and reliability.

The judge noted that arguments of bias fall flat against Reiter who has testified as an expert witness for Chicago in past police-misconduct lawsuits and also rejected some of Obrycka's other expert data.

"This is not the behavior of someone who is simply 'adopting' or 'parroting' Plaintiff's counsel's opinions in his report," St. Eve wrote on July 5.

Click to read complaint.
  Appeared here
 
  Filed Under:
 
 
  This is the Reader Comment Zone  
     Post comments about this story but please be respectful of each other  
  If you are a Registered user enter your User Name and Password, enter a comment then click SAVE  
  User name:   Password:    
         
  1500 characters maximum - no html. Characters remaining >>    
   
     
  Registration is required to post comments  

 
 
 
Attorney Lawrence Taylor, taser, my rights, police brutality pictures, police video, sheriff, Timeline, forum, Corruption, cop videos, arrest, taser, Johnson County Kansas, Johnson County, Attorney Lawrence Taylor, Judge Davis, Judge Franklin Davis, Mary Stephenson, entrapment, bad cop, bad cops, courts, law, watchdog group, abuse, beatdown, the law, Criminals, Corrupt copsCorruption, news, arrest, forum, police complaint, corrupt judge, police corruption, police oversight, fbi, police officer, police report, police investigation, abuse or power. watchdog, state police, sheriff, police corruption, speeding ticket, State Police Department, Police Department, Criminals, Timeline, police corruption, bad cop, law., police misconduct, bad cops,brutality, fbi, DUI, police brutality, beatdown, Corruption, taser, abuse, police beatdown, cop beatdown, watchdog, police corruption, internal affairs, federal corruption, presecutorial corruption, police scanner, code of ethics, police corruption. DUI, taser, my rights, police brutality pictures, Criminals. arrest, police brutality statistics, taser, police videoscop videos, police misconduct, Police misconduct, entrapment, Police Department, abuse or power, watchdog group, forum, Timeline, police corruption, bad cop, bad cops, Corruption, investigative reporting, beatdown, police crime, crime, law, Tax payers, Johnson County Kansas, Johnson County, police report police, police scanner, police corruption, code of ethics, cop videos, police cars, police brutality statistics, vehicle stops and rights, state police, State Police Department, sheriff, speeding ticket, Attorney Lawrence Taylor, Judge Davis, Judge Franklin Davis, police misconduct, Mary Stephenson
 
Hits from 65 countries World Wide     The World is Watching
Protected by International Copyright Laws © LawReport.org, 2006. All rights reserved.     Last Updated: 8/17/2014